What Brooklyn Workers Should Know Before Accepting a Workers’ Compensation Settlement

Work Injury Claim Form

An insurance carrier may offer a lump-sum settlement to close your workers’ compensation claim.

While the amount might seem substantial compared to your regular paychecks, accepting it could limit your right to future benefits, depending on the settlement terms.

For injured workers in Brooklyn, overdue bills and lost income can make the decision especially difficult.

The challenge is determining whether the settlement accounts for future medical treatment, ongoing wage losses, and the benefits being waived.

These are among the issues a Brooklyn workers’ compensation lawyer may examine when reviewing a settlement offer.

What a Section 32 Settlement Closes

In New York, most settlements run through Workers’ Compensation Law § 32.

Under that law, you and the insurer agree on a sum in exchange for ending the benefits the agreement covers.

The payment often comes as a lump sum, though some deals use an annuity.

The offer must state what part of the money is for wage benefits, what part is for medical care, and what part is for any attorney fee, according to the Board’s guidance.

Once the Board approves the deal, the decision is final. Section 32(c) bars review of an approval under Workers’ Compensation Law § 23, as a Third Department decision explains.

Only the parties can change the agreement later, and the Board must approve that change too, so a mistake in the terms is hard to undo.

When Offers Come and How Approval Works

Insurers must offer you a chance to settle within two years after the Board indexes your claim, or six months after you receive a permanent disability classification, whichever is later.

The Board must approve the deal unless it finds the agreement unfair, unconscionable, legally improper, or built on a deliberate lie about an important fact.

It will not approve anything until 10 calendar days after the filing, and the parties can still withdraw during that window.

After approval, the insurer must pay within 10 days or face a late-payment penalty under Workers’ Compensation Law § 25(3)(f).

The process follows this path:

  • Insurer’s offer
  • Board review
  • 10-day wait
  • Payment within 10 days

Future Medical Care and Medicare

Some settlements close medical care too.

If yours does, you pay for future treatment from the settlement money, so the amount set aside for medical needs matters.

The Board looks hard at deals that put less than 10 percent of the gross amount toward future medical care, unless you have no reason to expect more treatment.

Ask your doctor whether you will need surgery, therapy, or medicine in the coming years.

Federal law adds another layer. Under 42 U.S.C. § 1395y(b)(2), Medicare acts as a secondary payer to workers’ compensation.

The Board’s own claimant release form warns that ignoring Medicare’s interests may put your future Medicare coverage for the work injury at risk, and a Medicare set-aside is one way to address that.

What Comes Out of the Check

A settlement figure is not the money you take home.

If a lawyer represents you, Workers’ Compensation Law § 24(2)(f) sets the fee at 15 percent of the benefits the carrier pays under the agreement, and money set aside for future medical care does not count toward that fee.

The Board also checks for child support debt and will not approve a deal if you are behind, unless the proceeds pay it.

Ask the insurer to show how it splits the money into these parts:

  • Wage benefits
  • Future medical
  • Attorney fee
  • Debts paid

Terms Beyond the Dollar Amount

Read the whole agreement, because extra terms can change your life more than the number does.

Some deals ask you to resign from the job.

The Board gives those terms scrutiny, and it will not approve a deal that bars you from reapplying with your employer, since Workers’ Compensation Law §§ 120 and 125 protect injured workers from job discrimination.

Every promise must appear in the written agreement, because the Board rejects deals that depend on side agreements.

Watch for annuities too.

The Board requires the insurer to buy one from a life insurer rated A or better.

Still, it has no power over the annuity company, and New York’s guaranty fund may cover unpaid annuity benefits only up to $500,000 if the company fails.

Weighing the Offer Against Your Recovery

A settlement asks a bigger question than whether the number looks fair today.

It asks how you will pay for treatment, cover lost work, and handle your job a year or two from now.

Compare the offer with your likely treatment costs and your plans for work.

The Board requires every claimant to watch its “Settling Your Claim” video before signing a Section 32 deal, so watch it and ask the insurer for the full agreement in writing.

You have time to read the terms, and the 10-day waiting period gives you one more window to change your mind.

Tina Wolf
Tina Wolf has been working as a writer for several years. She enjoys researching and writing about the government and history as well as other legal topics. With extensive legal knowledge she verifies accuracy to the highest standards.

Leave Your Comment

Disclaimer: The content provided on this website is intended for informational purposes only.