Go to Page Section:
Wielding the gavel might sound like the ultimate power move—dishing out justice, commanding a courtroom, and wearing those iconic pitch-black robes.
But being a judge isn’t all dramatic verdicts and legal wisdom.
Behind the bench lies a world of immense responsibility, ethical tightropes, and emotional strain.
Sure, there’s prestige and purpose (and a lot of legal jargon), but also pressure and exposure to risk and danger depending on the court.
If you are considering a career as a judge, here is a short review of the pros and cons of life in the judicial hot seat.
Pros of Being a Judge
Keeping things fair is not always easy, but being a judge has some definite perks.
1. Public Service and Impact
A position behind the gavel opens opportunities to contribute meaningfully to justice and uphold the rule of law locally and nationally.
A judge can influence lives through a lifetime of decisions by developing a core understanding of a legal specialty.
Judges make decisions that can shape legal precedents, protect constitutional rights, and influence social policy.
The role requires deep legal reasoning, interpretation of laws, and application of principles to complex and often novel situations.
2. Intellectual Challenge
Everyone knows someone who can answer every ‘Jeopardy’ or Pub Trivia question.
Sometimes annoying, these clever individuals are always intellectually curious about the world.
Judges use their legal knowledge to solve a puzzle.
Not a crossword or a simple game of Sudoku, but a puzzle of innocence and legality.
The perfect judge’s personality often excels in complex reasoning skills, a pro for those who enjoy critical thinking and legal analysis.
3. Respect and Prestige
Being a judge is a great way to get a personalized or special license plate.
However, having a “J.” after your name or the title of “Honorable” to use for reservations at a restaurant is not the only benefit of being a judge.
Magistrates, whether elected or appointed, hold highly respected positions in society.
Judges can be turned to during local emergencies or when communities need impartial third-party determinations.
They are seen as symbols of fairness and integrity.
Legal referees are also considered moral and intellectual authorities within the legal system.
4. Job Stability
Judicial appointments, especially for federal and higher court judges, often come with tenure or long-term positions, offering unmatched job security.
However, judges behind lower or politically affiliated benches may be required to renew their commitment or run for reelection.
Elected judges may not have lifelong stability.
However, there is some comfort in knowing that the numerous qualifications required to achieve a judicial position, once completed, are hard to remove.
5. Reasonable Compensation and Potential
Judicial salaries vary by court, degree or legal specialty, experience, and even location.
In some states, not all bench positions require a law degree.
Thus, judges are not always the highest earners in the legal profession.
They typically receive competitive pay and state and government benefits, such as pensions, education credits, health insurance, and paid leave.
Some contracts even include free parking!
6. Professional Independence
Professional autonomy is at the heart of legal decisions.
Judges are considered free from micromanagement or repercussions for federal, district, or regional courts.
This allows decisions based on the law and conscience without political interference.
This independence is rare in other professions.
7. Lifelong Learning
Being a judge is a good career choice for individuals who love the law and want an intellectual challenge.
The American judicial system constantly evolves, and judges are responsible for keeping up with new laws, alternative interpretations of law and social policy, and the application of laws.
Legal precedents, a significant factor in legal opinions, also change as society changes.
Depending on your perspective, a profession that requires a lifelong commitment to learning can be a con or a pro.
However, there is also the opportunity to put all that information to good use by mentoring young lawyers and clerks, shaping the next generation of legal professionals.
Being a judge is rarely about personally determining guilt or innocence.
Instead, it is about maintaining control of the environment and ensuring objective adherence to the law.
Cons of Being a Judge
Maintaining impartiality and keeping everyone in the courtroom on track can take a toll. Here are several negative aspects of being a judge.
1. An Overwhelming Workload for Judges
The judiciary often follows a defined calendar and schedule, which can offer a more predictable work structure compared to private practice.
However, in many large urban settings, court is held day and night.
And within a set calendar, judges are expected to hear a significant number of cases daily.
Whether the legal specialty is family or criminal courts, judges spend long hours sitting, listening, verifying legal precedent, and writing opinions.
2. Public Scrutiny and Criticism of a Judge
Access to social and legacy media is everywhere.
Not every case will indeed end up on “Dateline” or “X”, but adjudication of an eminent or celebrity-driven case may attract significant attention.
Furthermore, controversial decisions have been known to create political backlash, demonstrations, and intense public criticism.
This may not be an optimal career choice if personal privacy is paramount.
3. Limited Freedoms of a Judge
Being in a courtroom, whether a person is a prosecutor, defendant, stenographer, or judge, is all about the law.
Judges are always expected to adhere to strict legal and ethical standards.
These professional rules may limit freedom of speech and personal or financial activities.
Outside of the courtroom, judges are still held to higher standards, projecting a persona of impartiality by refraining from public commentary on political or legal issues.
4. Professional Burnout of Judges
Long hours and hard work are always physically exhausting.
Making decisions that affect lives can result in emotional fatigue.
There are numerous professions, such as medicine, military personnel, and commercial airline pilots, where overwork and stress can create burnout.
Individuals working in law and law enforcement are also at risk.
Judges regularly hear cases through traumatic testimonies, revolving around abuse, family disputes, and violent crimes.
A steady diet of dealing with negative information can be a substantial con in this career choice.
5. Judges Who Must Run for Election
In many states and at the Federal level, judges are appointed for a set term or, as with the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS), for life.
However, 21 states, including New Mexico, North Carolina, Ohio, and Texas, require judges to be elected even at the higher levels.
A need to periodically run for office can increase public scrutiny and the daily stresses associated with local or circuit judicial decisions.
An election at any level also inserts a financial component into a career that should be fundamentally impartial.
6. Exposure to Security Risks as a Judge
A good judge focuses on impartiality.
However, in prominent legal discussions, especially in criminal or controversial civil cases, public emotions can cause reactions.
Political and policy decisions are also judicial situations that may create an insecure environment for judges and other legal personnel.
In these rare cases, judges can face personal threats and require governmental protection or private security measures for themselves and their families.
7. Slow Judicial Decision-Making Processes
The judicial bureaucracy and procedural rules are daunting and work at a perceived snail’s pace within the U.S. justice system.
This was intentionally designed.
Even though the United States legal system ensures a fair and ‘speedy’ trial, the country’s founders wanted to ensure a reasonable period to consider all the facts in a case calmly and completely, without emotion.
Unfortunately, some consider this slow-walk process counterproductive, frustrating judges who favor more dynamic legal environments.
Pros and Cons of Being a Judge – Summary Table
| Pros of Being a Judge | Cons of Being a Judge |
|---|---|
| 1. Public Service and Impact | 1. An Overwhelming Workload for Judges |
| 2. Intellectual Challenge | 2. Public Scrutiny and Criticism of a Judge |
| 3. Respect and Prestige | 3. Limited Freedoms of a Judge |
| 4. Job Stability | 4. Professional Burnout of Judges |
| 5. Reasonable Compensation and Potential | 5. Judges that Must Run for Election |
| 6. Professional Independence | 6. Exposure to Security Risks as a Judge |
| 7. Lifelong Learning | 7. Slow Judicial Decision-Making Processes |
Should You Become a Judge?
Although prestigious, a career as a judge is not just about offering a personal opinion.
Not all judicial positions indeed require a Juris Doctorate (J.D.), also referred to as a law degree.
However, even lower court positions such as Justice of the Peace do expect a unique blend of intellectual rigor, knowledge of appropriate laws, professional dedication, and public responsibility.
Judges play a vital role in upholding justice by setting the standards for a court’s independence and impartiality.
Yet, due to ethical constraints and public interest, the position can also be isolating and emotionally demanding.
Ultimately, the role of a judge, whether elected or appointed, is best suited for individuals who strive for intellectual curiosity, value fairness and integrity, and want their decisions to benefit society.
Leave a Reply